Grocery Bag Dysmorphic Disorder

Reusable grocery bags and I have a somewhat tumultuous history. For years, I spurned them in favor of disposable supermarket plastic bags, which played a critical role in my daily cat litter scooping routine. But then I switched to a different cat litter disposal strategy (I’ll spare you the details), broke free of my plastic bag dependency, and bought a couple reusable bags.

We got off to a great start, those first two bags and I. They came from Trader Joe’s, purveyor of fine foods and superior grocery bags. Approximately 92% of the reusable shopping bags you’ll see in Southern California are Trader Joe’s bags — I’m not sure how much of their popularity is due to actual bag quality and how much is due to the image they project. The Trader Joe’s bag is little classier than a regular supermarket bag, but less pretentious than a Whole Foods bag. It shows up in supermarkets, pet stores, and farmer’s markets. It’s Everybag.

My reusable bag honeymoon didn’t last long. I began to neglect the bags I’d once adored. I’d leave work at the end of the day intending to stop at the store on my way home, and then realize I didn’t have any bags with me. I’d postpone my shopping for a day — but then I’d forget the bags again the next day, and the next. Eventually, I’d run out of toilet paper or peanut butter or Sharpies or something, and I’d be unable to put it off any longer. In my despair and confusion I’d accept whatever bags they wanted to give me: plastic, paper, whatever. Once, I wound up with disposable bags made out of unicorn skins and industrial waste, assembled by 6-year-old girls working 18-hour shifts by candlelight in an abandoned coal mine. Clearly, something had to change.

My solution was to buy so many bags that there would always be some in my car. But then I discovered that I had a more serious problem: Grocery Bag Dysmorphic Disorder. I can never correctly estimate the number of bags I’ll need for the groceries I plan to buy. Often, I’ll bring in one bag and buy 2-3 bags worth of stuff. Once when I did this, a bagger actually managed to get everything into one bag — he approached it like a particularly challenging game of Tetris as I watched with ever-increasing fascination. I was amazed when he managed to get it to fit, and we shared a celebratory moment before I left the store. It was the high point of my day.

Other times, I’ll make the opposite mistake and bring in four bags when I’m buying three items, leaving the bagger to wonder whether I want them to stack the bags together to form one quadruple bag, or make two double bags and put some items in each, or leave the bags as singles and put the milk in one, the cereal in another, and open the egg carton and put six in each of the other two bags. I’m never quite sure which of these alternatives I want, either.

Very little is known about Grocery Bag Dysmorphic Disorder; in fact, a Google search for it returned literally no results. If anyone out there also suffers from this affliction, I just want you to know that you are not alone.

Check out today’s Dear Good Greatsby, in which my favorite advice columnist helps me out with an unrelated personal problem.

Tagged with: , , ,
Posted in Humor
19 comments on “Grocery Bag Dysmorphic Disorder
  1. notquiteold says:

    I buy another reuseable that always seem to wind up covered with cat hair. I’m embarrassed to bring it to the then another purchase. I end up buying a reuseable bag every time I shop…. so maybe not so reuseable after all?

  2. Hahaha…
    working with unicorn skulls is no easy task (even in full-on sunlight)!
    They’re so finicky!

  3. nursemyra says:

    I’d like a reusable grocery bag with a Tetris design on it

  4. eliserae says:

    I want a bag made of unicorn skin! That sounds most excellent.

    I just go into stores with big pockets. No bags, no hassle. Except for the part where I look like a weirdo. Oh, and now that google search yields four results, all of which are your blog. :)
    {As an aside, I like your writing… do you think you could take a look at my blog and consider submitting something?}

  5. Binky says:

    This is why it’s good to know how to make an improvised bag out out your shirt or jacket, so you’ll always be prepared.

  6. I have the same kitty waste disposal system, so plastic bags it is for me. Though I recycle the unused ones (no really, I do – that is NOT a four foot high pile of plastic you see in the breakfast nook) so I am still a friend of the unicorns.

    The Tetris game of bagging sounds like so much fun I might have to get myself a bag just to see it. I think we could start a national tournament.

  7. MC/Curtis says:

    My wife and I usually take two bags and fill two bags. Sometimes we only needed one and sometimes we go a few items over, but mostly we use two bags.
    At home we have way more bags than two. We should give away bags because we only ever use two but we seem to think they’ll wear out or we’ll suddenly need more bags.
    I’d guess that would be part of or a symptom of the disorder.

    I found a cardboard box that fit quite snug inside one of the bags. I removed the top flaps and now I have either a box with handles, or a bag with a solid interior. I’m not sure which it is, but it’s very handy.

    Also, my wife found a way to wrap the old plastic bags and tuck them into an empty baby wipes container so that now we have pull out bags kind of like a tissue box. We offer them to our customers when we sell our comics at events.

    Thanks for the article!

  8. […] the post Grocery Bag Dysmorphic Disorder (September 14, […]

  9. When I shop with the reusable bags, I always feel fat. They’re just not as flattering as putting a paper bag over my head.

Leave a comment. Please.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Elsewhere …

I have some publications in other places, including short stories at Shimmer, Flash Fiction Online, and Daily Science Fiction, and a list of overly-wordy LOLCat captions on McSweeney's.

Things I found in my cat's water bowl.

A blog about my cat Holly's end of life.

Follow Unlikely Explanations on

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Less Recent Posts
The Archives page has links to every post that's ever appeared on this blog.
Not what you were looking for?
If a search engine brought you here while you were looking for something else, please see An Open Letter to Anyone Who Was Directed Here by a Search Engine.
Unlikely Tweets
Freshly Pegged
%d bloggers like this: